Home / Glossary / Decisional balance
Glossary
Decisional balance and Motivational Interviewing
Decisional balance is an exercise that weighs the pros and cons of changing and of staying the same. It is often taught alongside Motivational Interviewing, but it is a different approach, and Miller and Rollnick caution against using it when the goal is to help someone move toward change.
What a decisional balance looks like
| Changing | Staying the same | |
|---|---|---|
| Benefits | Good things about making the change | Good things about keeping things as they are |
| Costs | Downsides of making the change | Downsides of keeping things as they are |
How it differs from MI
A decisional balance explores both sides of ambivalence evenly. MI is intentionally directional: it gives more attention to the person’s own change talk while respecting their choice. Miller and Rose (2015) reviewed this difference and concluded that with people who are still ambivalent, a full pros-and-cons exercise tends to weaken commitment to change, while evoking change talk supports it.
When decisional balance fits
It fits when a helper wants to stay neutral and not influence which way a person decides. Miller and Rollnick call this counseling with neutrality. An example is helping someone weigh two treatment options when either would be a reasonable choice. Miller and Rose also note that once a person has already decided to change, reviewing pros and cons may strengthen their commitment.
Miller and Rollnick (2009) list decisional balance among the things MI is not, because the two are often confused.
Put it into practice with your team
Reading about Motivational Interviewing is a good start. Training is the beginning, not the finish line: the skill sticks when people practice it in the conversations they actually have. If your team is working on this, tell us about your workforce and where conversations get stuck, or explore foundational Motivational Interviewing training.
